Can the next dispatcher make the right list?
AI Change Desk / EP053 / 45-minute paper exercise
Friday's dispatcher fixed one report. Monday's dispatcher inherits the saved rule, not Friday's conversation. Find out whether that distinction changes who gets a repair crew. Use invented records only. No account, customer data or live system is needed.
Dispatcher and facilitator | Keep this sheet private
0-5 minutes | Pick one decision. Which repairs should the duty dispatcher give a crew this morning? Name the person who can edit the saved rule and the person who can accept what the list means. These are different responsibilities even if one person holds both.
Report and decision: ____________________ Maintainer: ____________________ Service owner: ____________________
5-15 minutes | Read the three ticket cards on the next sheet. Before showing anyone a report, write the IDs you expect to dispatch and why. Keep this answer folded or on a separate slip until the comparison.
Expected IDs: ____________________ Reason: ____________________
15-25 minutes | Hand the incoming dispatcher the ticket sheet, a copy of the saved rule and its revision. Keep the one-off Friday correction separate: "Add the reopened Maple Street repair to this report." Do not explain what the saved rule was meant to say.
Incoming dispatcher | Work from this sheet alone
25-35 minutes | Build the list by applying the saved rule to the current ticket cards. If you cannot tell what the rule means, record the ambiguity. Do not ask the outgoing dispatcher for the intended answer.
Sample saved rule, revision A: "List newly opened repairs that need a crew." Use this rule as written, or substitute an invented saved instruction and label its revision before starting.
R17 | New repair opened this morning. A crew is needed.
R18 | Repair marked closed Friday. Reopened overnight. A crew is needed.
R19 | Repair completed Friday. Still closed. No crew requested.
Revision actually used: ____________________ IDs you would dispatch (one line per visit): ____________________
Wording that decided a borderline case: __________________________________________________
Stop here until the dispatcher has independently written the expected list.
Reveal debrief after both lists are complete
Debrief | Open only after both lists exist
35-45 minutes | Compare by identifier. For this fictional service the intended list is R17 and R18, once each; R19 stays off. A missing R18 means an open visit could be missed. Adding R19 means a crew could be sent back to a completed job. Neither result is evidence about a real vendor's software.
Missing / extra / duplicated visits: ____________________ Which words in the saved rule explain the result? ____________________
If the lists differ, propose one revision that admits the reopened repair while leaving the completed repair off. If they agree, give the handoff to someone new: can they find the same revision and the person to call without a hint?
Proposed wording or handoff repair: __________________________________________________
Service owner's decision (accept intended meaning / return for clarification): ____________________
Maintainer and saved revision to revisit: ____________________ Dispatcher accepting the fresh list: ____________________
Next check (person, date and time): ____________________ If the list looks wrong, hold the send and contact: ____________________
Fallback the person on duty can actually use: __________________________________________________
Leave with an owner and a next check, not permission to change production.